The polls from Max's pins, with every answer linked. Tap any answer to see what it is, whether it thins the blood, and what makes it different. Two questions per sore spot: what you swallow, and what you rub on, wear, wrap or soak in.

The pill cabinet · oral OTC
Knee barking after leg day. What do you reach for first?
What it isIbuprofen 200 mg. Calms pain and inflammation (swelling).
What sets it apartThe classic. Works in about 30 minutes and lasts 4 to 6 hours, so you may need a second dose later in the day.
Heads-upTake with food. Skip it or ask first with stomach ulcers, kidney problems, heart disease or high blood pressure. Don't stack it with other NSAIDs like Aleve or aspirin.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isNaproxen sodium 220 mg. Calms pain and inflammation.
What sets it apartLasts the longest of the pills here: one caplet can cover 8 to 12 hours, so fewer doses a day.
Heads-upTake with food or water. Don't combine with ibuprofen or aspirin. Ask first with stomach, kidney, heart or blood-pressure issues.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isAcetaminophen 650 mg, extended release.
What sets it apartNot an NSAID, so it's easier on the stomach but doesn't reduce swelling. The two-layer caplet lasts up to 8 hours.
Heads-upHard on the liver in high doses: stay under the label's daily max, count acetaminophen in cold and sleep meds, and limit alcohol.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isTurmeric curcumin with black pepper extract (BioPerine) to help absorption.
What sets it apartA dietary supplement, not a pain medicine. Some people take it daily for joint stiffness; it builds up over weeks, not hours.
Heads-upSupplements aren't FDA-approved to treat pain. Ask first if you take blood thinners or diabetes meds, or have gallbladder issues.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›Rub · wear · wrap · soak
Knee says no. Which one's coming off the shelf?
What it isDiclofenac 1% gel, the first prescription-strength arthritis gel sold over the counter.
What sets it apartThe only rub-on here with a real anti-inflammatory medicine in it. Best for joints near the skin like knees and hands. Works best used 4 times a day for several days.
Heads-upDon't use with NSAID pills without asking. Wash your hands after, keep it off broken skin, and don't cover it with heat.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isKnee compression sleeves, 2-pack, with copper-infused fabric.
What sets it apartLight, all-day support and warmth for the knee. The compression is what helps; copper itself isn't proven to do much.
Heads-upShould feel snug, not tight. Take it off if your foot tingles or swells.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isKinesiology tape, pre-cut strips.
What sets it apartLight, flexible support you can wear through a workout and a shower. Some guys swear by it, and it's cheap to try.
Heads-upTest a small strip first if your skin is sensitive. Peel slowly with some oil.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isReusable gel ice pack that straps around the knee.
What sets it apartCold is the move for a fresh tweak or swelling. The wrap holds it in place hands-free.
Heads-up15 to 20 minutes at a time with a cloth barrier, then give the skin a break.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›
The pill cabinet · oral OTC
Shoulder tight after pressing day. What do you take?
What it isTwo medicines in one caplet: ibuprofen 125 mg plus acetaminophen 250 mg.
What sets it apartThe only two-in-one on the list. It hits pain from two directions at lower doses of each.
Heads-upContains acetaminophen, so don't take it with Tylenol or anything else that has acetaminophen. Same NSAID cautions as Advil, and go easy on alcohol.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isNaproxen sodium 220 mg. Calms pain and inflammation.
What sets it apartLasts the longest of the pills here: one caplet can cover 8 to 12 hours, so fewer doses a day.
Heads-upTake with food or water. Don't combine with ibuprofen or aspirin. Ask first with stomach, kidney, heart or blood-pressure issues.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isAcetaminophen 500 mg.
What sets it apartNot an NSAID, so it's gentler on the stomach and kidneys. It eases pain but won't bring swelling down.
Heads-upWatch the daily max and other products with acetaminophen. Limit alcohol. Ask first with liver problems.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isAspirin 325 mg. Eases pain and inflammation.
What sets it apartThe only true blood thinner on this list. Great for pain, but it's the one to skip if you already take a blood thinner or bruise easily.
Heads-upDon't mix with ibuprofen, naproxen or other blood thinners without asking. Take with food. Stop before surgery or dental work if told to.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›Rub · wear · wrap · soak
Shoulder still talking the next morning. What goes on it?
What it isMedicated patch, typically methyl salicylate with menthol (and camphor in some versions).
What sets it apartStick it on and forget it for hours. Good for a shoulder or back you can't keep rubbing.
Heads-upCheck the box for the exact ingredients. Skip it with an aspirin allergy. Don't use with a heating pad, on broken skin, or longer than the label says.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isCream with menthol and methyl salicylate.
What sets it apartThe cold-then-hot feeling distracts from the ache. Strong and quick, but it doesn't fix inflammation like Voltaren does.
Heads-upWash hands after and keep it away from eyes. Never use with a heating pad or tight wrap (burn risk). Check first if you're on a blood thinner.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isReusable ice pack wrap shaped for the shoulder.
What sets it apartCovers the whole shoulder cap, which a regular ice pack keeps sliding off of.
Heads-up15 to 20 minutes at a time with a thin layer between, then a break.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isDeep tissue percussion massage gun.
What sets it apartHits knots in shoulders, back and legs harder than your hands can, and fast.
Heads-upStay off bones, joints and the front of the neck. Skip fresh injuries and swollen areas.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›
The pill cabinet · oral OTC
Stood up too fast and the lower back locked. Pick your pill.
What it isNaproxen sodium 220 mg, packaged for back and muscle pain.
What sets it apartSame active ingredient as regular Aleve. The difference is the label, not the medicine.
Heads-upSame as Aleve: with food, no mixing with other NSAIDs, ask first with stomach, kidney, heart or blood-pressure issues.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isIbuprofen 200 mg. Calms pain and inflammation (swelling).
What sets it apartThe classic. Works in about 30 minutes and lasts 4 to 6 hours, so you may need a second dose later in the day.
Heads-upTake with food. Skip it or ask first with stomach ulcers, kidney problems, heart disease or high blood pressure. Don't stack it with other NSAIDs like Aleve or aspirin.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isAcetaminophen 500 mg.
What sets it apartNot an NSAID, so it's gentler on the stomach and kidneys. It eases pain but won't bring swelling down.
Heads-upWatch the daily max and other products with acetaminophen. Limit alcohol. Ask first with liver problems.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isMagnesium glycinate 400 mg.
What sets it apartNot a pain reliever. Some guys take it in the evening for muscle cramps and sleep. Glycinate is the gentle-on-the-stomach form.
Heads-upToo much can loosen stools. Ask first with kidney disease or if you take antibiotics or thyroid meds (timing matters).
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›Rub · wear · wrap · soak
Back is stiff. What are you buying tonight?
What it isAir-activated heat wrap that stays warm for about 8 hours.
What sets it apartDrug-free and wearable under a shirt, so it works at your desk or in the car. Heat loosens tight, stiff muscles.
Heads-upDon't sleep in it or use it with rub-ons. Skip heat on a fresh injury (first 48 hours) or if you have poor skin sensation.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isMagnesium sulfate bath soak with essential oils.
What sets it apartA warm-water ritual for the whole body. The heat and the time off your feet do most of the work.
Heads-upKeep the bath warm, not hot. Don't soak a fresh, swollen injury; ice it first.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isLower back brace with adjustable straps.
What sets it apartSupport for a day of lifting, standing or driving when the back is cranky.
Heads-upShort-term help only. Wearing it all day every day can weaken the muscles you need. Pain down the leg gets a doctor.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isMenthol roll-on.
What sets it apartPure cooling, no aspirin-type ingredient, and the roll-on keeps your hands clean. The easiest pick if you're on other meds.
Heads-upDon't use with heat or a tight wrap. Keep off broken skin and away from eyes.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›
The pill cabinet · oral OTC
Long night over the decks, neck is stiff. What do you grab?
What it isIbuprofen 200 mg in a liquid-filled capsule.
What sets it apartSame medicine as regular Advil. The liquid gel usually kicks in a little faster.
Heads-upSame rules as Advil tablets: with food, no stacking with other NSAIDs, ask first with stomach, kidney, heart or blood-pressure issues.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isAcetaminophen 500 mg plus caffeine 65 mg (about half a cup of coffee).
What sets it apartBuilt for tension headaches and neck tightness. Unlike Excedrin Extra Strength, this one has no aspirin.
Heads-upCount it toward your daily acetaminophen. The caffeine can keep you up if you take it late at night.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isNaproxen sodium 220 mg. Calms pain and inflammation.
What sets it apartLasts the longest of the pills here: one caplet can cover 8 to 12 hours, so fewer doses a day.
Heads-upTake with food or water. Don't combine with ibuprofen or aspirin. Ask first with stomach, kidney, heart or blood-pressure issues.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isAcetaminophen 500 mg.
What sets it apartNot an NSAID, so it's gentler on the stomach and kidneys. It eases pain but won't bring swelling down.
Heads-upWatch the daily max and other products with acetaminophen. Limit alcohol. Ask first with liver problems.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›Rub · wear · wrap · soak
Neck kink that will not quit. What is your fix?
What it isContoured cervical support pillow.
What sets it apartFixes the cause instead of the symptom: keeps the neck in line while you sleep.
Heads-upGive it a week; a new pillow can feel strange at first.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isElectric heating pad shaped for the neck and shoulders.
What sets it apartSteady, adjustable heat you can reuse every night, drug-free.
Heads-upUse the auto shut-off, keep a layer between pad and skin, and don't fall asleep on it.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isCamphor 11% and menthol 11% in a herbal balm.
What sets it apartA thick balm with a strong scent and warm tingle. Old-school, and a little goes a long way.
Heads-upStrong smell. Wash hands after. Don't use with heat, on broken skin, or near eyes.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isMedicated patch, typically methyl salicylate with menthol (and camphor in some versions).
What sets it apartStick it on and forget it for hours. Good for a shoulder or back you can't keep rubbing.
Heads-upCheck the box for the exact ingredients. Skip it with an aspirin allergy. Don't use with a heating pad, on broken skin, or longer than the label says.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›
The pill cabinet · oral OTC
Achilles tight after the walk. What is in your cabinet?
What it isIbuprofen 200 mg. Calms pain and inflammation (swelling).
What sets it apartThe classic. Works in about 30 minutes and lasts 4 to 6 hours, so you may need a second dose later in the day.
Heads-upTake with food. Skip it or ask first with stomach ulcers, kidney problems, heart disease or high blood pressure. Don't stack it with other NSAIDs like Aleve or aspirin.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isNaproxen sodium 220 mg. Calms pain and inflammation.
What sets it apartLasts the longest of the pills here: one caplet can cover 8 to 12 hours, so fewer doses a day.
Heads-upTake with food or water. Don't combine with ibuprofen or aspirin. Ask first with stomach, kidney, heart or blood-pressure issues.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isAcetaminophen 650 mg, extended release.
What sets it apartNot an NSAID, so it's easier on the stomach but doesn't reduce swelling. The two-layer caplet lasts up to 8 hours.
Heads-upHard on the liver in high doses: stay under the label's daily max, count acetaminophen in cold and sleep meds, and limit alcohol.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isFish oil omega-3 (EPA + DHA).
What sets it apartA daily supplement for overall joint and heart support, not a quick fix for a sore spot.
Heads-upTake with a meal to avoid fishy burps. Ask first if you take blood thinners or have a fish allergy.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›Rub · wear · wrap · soak
Heel cord grumbling. What do you buy?
What it isGel heel cups, 2-pack.
What sets it apartLifts and cushions the heel, which takes some pull off a tight Achilles. Goes in any shoe.
Heads-upUse in both shoes to stay even.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isAnkle compression sleeve.
What sets it apartGentle support and swelling control around the ankle and Achilles, thin enough for a shoe.
Heads-upSnug, not tight. Not a brace for a bad sprain.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isReusable ice pack wrap for the ankle and heel.
What sets it apartWraps around the back of the ankle where the Achilles is, so you can ice with your foot up.
Heads-up15 to 20 minutes at a time with a cloth barrier. Sudden sharp heel pain or a pop gets a doctor, not ice.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isDiclofenac 1% gel, the first prescription-strength arthritis gel sold over the counter.
What sets it apartThe only rub-on here with a real anti-inflammatory medicine in it. Best for joints near the skin like knees and hands. Works best used 4 times a day for several days.
Heads-upDon't use with NSAID pills without asking. Wash your hands after, keep it off broken skin, and don't cover it with heat.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›
The pill cabinet · oral OTC
Calf grabbed on you mid-set. What do you take?
What it isIbuprofen 200 mg. Calms pain and inflammation (swelling).
What sets it apartThe classic. Works in about 30 minutes and lasts 4 to 6 hours, so you may need a second dose later in the day.
Heads-upTake with food. Skip it or ask first with stomach ulcers, kidney problems, heart disease or high blood pressure. Don't stack it with other NSAIDs like Aleve or aspirin.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isNaproxen sodium 220 mg. Calms pain and inflammation.
What sets it apartLasts the longest of the pills here: one caplet can cover 8 to 12 hours, so fewer doses a day.
Heads-upTake with food or water. Don't combine with ibuprofen or aspirin. Ask first with stomach, kidney, heart or blood-pressure issues.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isAcetaminophen 500 mg.
What sets it apartNot an NSAID, so it's gentler on the stomach and kidneys. It eases pain but won't bring swelling down.
Heads-upWatch the daily max and other products with acetaminophen. Limit alcohol. Ask first with liver problems.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isSugar-free electrolyte powder (sodium, potassium, magnesium).
What sets it apartNot a medicine. Calves and feet often cramp when you're low on fluid and salts after a sweaty session or a long night out.
Heads-upCheck the sodium if you're on a low-salt diet or blood-pressure meds.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›Rub · wear · wrap · soak
Calf still tight the next day. What is your go-to?
What it isCalf compression sleeves, 3 pairs.
What sets it apartSqueezes the calf to cut down on the post-workout ache and that heavy-leg feeling.
Heads-upSnug, not tight. Ask first if you have circulation problems or diabetes.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isFirm foam roller.
What sets it apartThe cheapest recovery tool there is. Slow rolling loosens tight calves, quads and upper back.
Heads-upRoll muscles, not joints or the lower back. Slow and steady beats hard and fast.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isHandheld muscle roller stick.
What sets it apartEasier than a foam roller when getting on the floor isn't happening. Great for calves and shins.
Heads-upModerate pressure. Stop if it causes sharp pain.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›What it isMagnesium sulfate bath soak with essential oils.
What sets it apartA warm-water ritual for the whole body. The heat and the time off your feet do most of the work.
Heads-upKeep the bath warm, not hot. Don't soak a fresh, swollen injury; ice it first.
Need to restock? Shop on Amazon ›Not medical advice. Follow the label, and check with a doctor or pharmacist before taking pain relievers, especially if you take blood thinners or have stomach, kidney, liver or heart issues. Sharp pain, swelling, or pain that lasts more than a few days gets a doctor visit, not a poll.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links (#ad). Max Reverb is an AI-created character.